Urban vs Rural

Populations, Communities, Administration​

Part One

While architectural historians are often concerned with the design, inception, and construction of buildings and objects, writing the history of architecture also includes the study of renovations, modifications, and changes in use of such spaces embedded in political and social contexts. In this episode, Heghnar Watenpaugh revisits her 2004 monograph entitled The Image of an Ottoman City in a discussion of Ottoman interventions into the historical urban geography of the empire’s third largest city, Aleppo, and talks about methods of reconstructing the lived urban environment of a city in Ottoman Syria.
Port Cities, Settler Colonies, and Plantations​
Model of a Colonial Port City
View of the market in Goa
Jan Huygen van Linschoten (copied after), Joannes / Baptista à / van Doetechum (engraver / etcher), Cornelis Claesz (publisher), Pieter Hoogerbeets (writer)
Source: Wikimedia Commons

 

Colonial Port City are geographically small but represent a long-lasting and important form in Asian empires. Portuguese Goa the first. Today, some are independent nations. Others sites of crucial global megacities. Others continuing political hotspots. Sites of early modern trade, but also military fortification and administrative hubs. Show of force usually against other Europeans. Begin with consent of nearby powers, usually. Diversity of population in concentrated area key to their function.

Key to the East: Jan Huygen van Linschoten’s 'Itinerario'

For most of the 17th century the Dutch East India Company, or VOC, brought wealth and prestige to the Low Countries, ushering in what would be known as the Dutch Golden Age. Business was booming, profits were soaring, and the greatly expanded middle class flaunted its newly acquired wealth. It was an age of masterpiece paintings and scientific breakthroughs. What allowed the VOC, established in 1602, to amass such vast fortunes at breakneck speed? The answer lies with the book that has been dubbed ‘the key to the East’: Jan Huygen van Linschoten’s Itinerario.

Source: Key to the East: Jan Huygen van Linschoten’s ‘Itinerario’ (Click Here)  

Atlas of Mutual Heritage

The Atlas of Mutual Heritage is a growing database containing information about, and images of, the charter areas of the VOC (Dutch East India Company) and WIC (Dutch West India Company).

Model of the Settler Colony
Governance at Sri Lanka
by Jan Brandes (d. 1808)
Source: Rijksmuseum, NG-1985-7-1-9

Idea: establishment of strategic foothold through the settlement and natural reproduction of an imported population. Can be ethnically or racially the same as the empire (Dutch and other white settlers in southern Africa), or racially mixed (Portuguese/Mestizo at Goa or Dutch/Mestizo at Sri Lanka), or can be a third imported group (Chinese at Taiwan). In many ways, this form is the archetypal system of colonization, possibly the oldest (Iceland), and not exclusive to Asia. Main point: ethnic inequality and exclusion are planned into this way of asserting colonial control. Touch on Patrick Wolfe: settler colonialism is a structure (not an event) that seeks to erase the indigenous population and claim their land through that elimination and new legal regimes.

White Residents at Sri Lanka by Jan Brandes
Source: Rijksmuseum, NG-1985-7-2-17
Map of Towns and Settlements in Taiwan
Source: The National Archives of the Netherlands, The Hague, Kaarten Leupe, 4.VEL, inv.nr. 1127
Model of a Plantation Colony
The Fort of Banda by Schley, Jacobus van der
Source: Kessler Collection

Most characteristic of early modern Caribbean, but present from an early period in Asia, and will expand to become the geographically largest form of European colonialism in Asia in the 19th and 20th centuries with products like sugar and rubber. These can be devastatingly brutal when they are formed, as in Banda and Amboina where spice plantation colonies were created through genocide. They always rely on unfree labor systems, so they encourage the growth of racially based slave trades, and then later the indentured servant or “coolie” trade.

Trade in Banda, Langenes, Barent (publisher), Anoniem / Anonymous (engraver / etcher)
Source: Rijksmuseum, RP-P-OB-75-390
Nutmeg from Banda ( anonymous)
Source: Rijksmuseum, RP-P-OB-75.396
Cities and Rural Areas in Late Imperial China

Part Two

Cities (Inland, port, etc.)

Beijing, Canton, and Macao

How shall we understand the twin city system in early modern metropolitan cities?

Key Issues
Required Readings

Goa, Batavia, Manila, and Deshima Compared

Why were urban ports central to early modern European intrusions into Asia?

Key Issues
Required Readings
Beijing, Canton, and Macao

Metropolitan city of inner Asia. “twin city” structure (Manchu and Han cities), religion and temples, occidentalism in palace architecture

Qing Peking
The designated quarters for the Eight Banners are shown in the Inner City, the Five Boroughs in the Outer City
Source: Susan Nacquin (2000), Peking: Temples and City Life, 356
The Old Summer Palace by Yi Lantai
Source: Wikimedia Commons
Tower of Tibetan Buddhism
Source: Wikibeijing
View of Canton c. 1800 China
Source: MIT Visualizing Culture
Canton, City and Environs,1858 by Lee Mum Un
Source: MIT Visualizing Culture
Goa, Batavia, Manila, and Deshima Compared

Why were urban ports central to early modern European intrusions into Asia? Stress that the cities often existed as “twins” of cities under the rule of Asian polities. They were a sign of both strength and weakness by European powers. They emerged only with the consent, tacit or explicit, of neighboring powers. These are not part of a story of the “great divergence” or European dominance. But paradoxically for those living in them, they could be oppressive, and they sometimes provided the basis for the extension of European territoriality in Asia.